Home / Point and Return Rate Guides
How to Choose a Credit Card by Return Rate
General information only. Point programs and their terms change; always confirm current conditions on the issuer's official page.
To choose a credit card based on return rates, you must calculate the net value of points earned against your specific spending habits while accounting for annual fees and usage limitations. Instead of looking at the highest advertised percentage, you should identify your largest monthly spending categories, determine which cards offer the highest base return for those specific categories, and then subtract the cost of the card's annual fee to find the actual profit.
Identify Your Primary Spending Categories
Before looking at any card offers, you need a clear picture of where your money goes each month. Credit card return rates are rarely uniform; a card might offer a high return on department store purchases but a very low return on utility bills or convenience store visits.
List your monthly expenses and group them into categories. Common categories include:
- Fixed Costs: Rent, electricity, water, gas, and mobile phone bills.
- Groceries and Dining: Supermarket trips, frequent convenience store visits, and restaurant meals.
- Transportation: Train fares, bus rides, and gasoline for your vehicle.
- Leisure and Shopping: Online shopping, hobby supplies, and entertainment.
Once you have these totals, you can see which category represents the largest portion of your monthly outflow. If 60% of your spending is on groceries, a card with a high grocery return rate is more valuable to you than a card that offers a high return on travel you only take once a year.
Understand Base Rates, Conditions, and Caps
When you research cards, you will see different types of return rates. It is essential to distinguish between the "base" rate and "special" rates.
Base Return Rates
The base rate is the standard percentage of points you earn on every yen spent. This is the most reliable way to measure a card's value for everyday spending. If a card offers a 0.5% base rate, you earn 0.5 points for every 100 yen spent, regardless of the merchant.
Category Bonuses and Caps
Many cards offer "boosted" rates for specific categories, such as 3.0% back on "online shopping" or 2.0% back on "gasoline." However, these often come with conditions:
- Spending Caps: You might only earn the boosted rate on the first 50,000 yen spent per month.
- Specific Merchants: The bonus might only apply to a specific group of partner stores, not all stores in that category.
- Minimum Spend Requirements: Some cards require you to spend a certain amount before the bonus rate kicks in.
Always check the issuer's official page to see if a high percentage is limited by a monthly cap. A 5% return rate that is capped at 5,000 points per month stops earning the bonus at 100,000 yen of spending (5,000 / 0.05). If spending above the cap earns nothing extra, an uncapped 1.5% card earns more only once monthly spending in that category passes about 333,000 yen (5,000 / 0.015).
Account for Annual Fees and Expiry
A high return rate does not always result in a profit if the cost of maintaining the card is too high. You must factor in the annual fee into your final calculation.
Furthermore, you must consider the "liquidity" of the points. Some points are easy to use (like being able to pay for your next credit card bill), while others can only be used at specific stores or for specific products. If you find it difficult to use the points you earn, the effective return rate is essentially zero.
Check the following for every card you consider:
- Annual Fee: Is it a flat fee, or does it decrease after a certain amount of spending?
- Point Expiry: Do the points expire after one year, two years, or never?
- Redemption Methods: Can you convert the points into cash, other points, or direct payments?
The Break-Even Method
To determine which card is truly better, use the break-even method. This involves calculating the total annual points earned and subtracting the annual fee to see the net gain.
Compare two hypothetical cards to see how this works in practice. Suppose your total annual spending is 960,000 yen (an average of 80,000 yen per month).
Card A:
- Base Return Rate: 1.0%
- Annual Fee: 0 yen
- Calculation: 960,000 yen × 0.01 = 9,600 points.
- Net Annual Value: 9,600 points.
Card B:
- Base Return Rate: 1.5%
- Annual Fee: 3,300 yen
- Calculation: 960,000 yen × 0.015 = 14,400 points.
- Subtract Fee: 14,400 - 3,300 = 11,100.
- Net Annual Value: 11,100 points.
In this scenario, even though Card B has a higher fee, it provides a net gain of 1,500 yen more than Card A (assuming 1 point = 1 yen) because the higher return rate outweighs the cost of the fee. However, if your annual spending were lower, the fee might make Card B less profitable than Card A.
| Comparison Factor | Card A | Card B |
|---|---|---|
| Annual Spending | 960,000 yen | 960,000 yen |
| Return Rate | 1.0% | 1.5% |
| Total Points Earned | 9,600 | 14,400 |
| Annual Fee | 0 yen | 3,300 yen |
| Net Value | 9,600 points | 11,100 points |
Simplify Your Strategy
While it may be tempting to hold multiple cards to maximize every single point, this often leads to "point fragmentation." This happens when you earn small amounts of different points across many different programs, making it difficult to accumulate enough to actually use them.
For most consumers, the most efficient strategy is to choose one primary card that covers the majority of your spending. This allows you to concentrate your points into a single pool that is easier to track and redeem. Use your primary card for your largest spending categories and only consider a second card if it offers a significantly higher return on a specific, high-volume category that your primary card ignores.
You can use the return rate calculator to enter your yearly spending, the earning rule, the annual fee and the return rate of a free card, and see the real return rate and break-even spend.
Check before you decide
- Verify the exact base return rate on the issuer's official page.
- Confirm if there are monthly caps on "bonus" categories.
- Check the annual fee and see if there are ways to waive it.
- Look for the point expiration date.
- Ensure the points can be used for the types of purchases you actually make.
- Calculate your net annual value using the break-even method before signing up.